Are Parking Lot Accidents Always 50/50?

Parking lot accidents can be frustrating and confusing, leaving both parties involved unsure of who is at fault and how the situation should be handled. Many people believe that in parking lot collisions, fault is automatically shared equally between both drivers, often referred to as the “50/50 rule.” However, is this assumption always accurate? In this article, we will delve into the intricacies of parking lot accidents, explore fault determination rules, and shed light on common misconceptions surrounding these incidents. If you have been involved in a parking lot accident, it’s essential to understand your rights and seek professional legal advice. Contact the experienced car accident attorneys at Arnona Rose Law Firm to ensure your interests are protected.

Understanding Fault Determination in Parking Lot Accidents

1. The Feeder Lane Myth

In parking lots, feeder lanes are frequently misunderstood areas. These lanes, typically located at the entrance or exit of parking lots, often have different rules of the road compared to other sections. Contrary to popular belief, the presence of a feeder lane does not automatically make an accident 50/50. The determination of fault in these situations depends on various factors, such as right-of-way and adherence to traffic signs.

2. Rules of the Road Still Apply

Although parking lots may seem like a more relaxed driving environment, the basic rules of the road still apply. Stop signs, yield signs, and other traffic signs within parking lots must be obeyed to maintain order and prevent accidents. Failing to yield the right-of-way or ignoring traffic signs can contribute to determining fault in a parking lot collision.

3. Examining Property Damages

When determining fault in a parking lot accident, insurance companies and legal professionals consider the extent of property damages. Evaluating the angle of impact, the location of damages on both vehicles, and any additional evidence can assist in determining which party bears the majority of the responsibility. It is crucial to document the damages and gather as much evidence as possible to support your case.

4. Common Parking Lot Scenarios

a. Rear-End Collisions: When one car collides with the rear end of another in a parking lot, the driver who struck the other vehicle is typically deemed at fault. Drivers should maintain a safe following distance to avoid rear-end collisions, even in parking lots.

b. Parked Cars: If a moving vehicle collides with a parked car, the responsibility generally falls on the moving vehicle’s driver. Parking spaces are expected to be clear, and drivers should exercise caution when maneuvering around parked vehicles.

c. Intersection Accidents: Parking lots often have intersections where cars converge from different directions. In such cases, the driver who fails to yield the right-of-way or ignores traffic signs may be considered at fault.

5. Fault Determination Rules

Although fault determination rules may vary by jurisdiction, some regions have established specific guidelines for parking lot accidents. These guidelines take into account factors such as traffic signs, speed limits, right-of-way, and the duty of care expected from drivers. Understanding the applicable fault determination rules in your area can help clarify the process of determining fault in a parking lot accident.


Parking lot accidents are not automatically 50/50, contrary to popular belief. Understanding the intricacies of fault determination rules and recognizing common misconceptions is crucial for accurately assessing liability in these situations. If you have been involved in a parking lot accident resulting in personal injury or property damage, it is essential to consult with a knowledgeable car accident attorney. We have extensive experience in handling parking lot accidents and can provide you with the guidance and representation you need. Contact us today to protect your rights and seek the compensation you deserve.

If you have been involved in a parking lot accident and require legal assistance, don’t hesitate to contact Arnona Rose Law Firm. Our dedicated team of car accident attorneys is ready to fight for your rights and provide the support you need. Schedule a consultation today.

Frequently Asked Questions

What type of crashes happen most often in parking lots?

In parking lots, various types of crashes can occur, but some common types of accidents happen more frequently than others. Here are the most common types of crashes that tend to occur in parking lots:

1. Rear-End Collisions: Rear-end collisions are a common occurrence in parking lots. They happen when a driver fails to maintain a safe following distance and ends up striking the vehicle in front of them. This type of accident often occurs when a driver is distracted, not paying attention, or misjudges the distance between vehicles.

2. Backing Collisions: Backing collisions occur when a driver backs out of a parking space and collides with a vehicle or pedestrian behind them. These accidents can happen when the backing driver fails to check their blind spots, relies solely on mirrors instead of physically looking around, or doesn’t proceed with caution.

3. Intersection Collisions: Parking lots have intersections where vehicles traveling in different directions converge. Intersection collisions can happen when drivers fail to yield the right-of-way, ignore traffic signs or signals, or misjudge the timing of other vehicles. These accidents often result from a lack of awareness or impatience.

4. Side-Swipe Collisions: Side-swipe collisions occur when the sides of two vehicles come into contact with each other while maneuvering through a parking lot. This can happen when two vehicles are traveling in parallel or when one vehicle is attempting to change lanes without checking blind spots.

5. Door Dings: While not as severe as other types of accidents, door dings are a common annoyance in parking lots. They occur when a driver opens their door without being mindful of the surrounding vehicles, resulting in minor damage to the adjacent car.

It’s important to note that these common types of crashes in parking lots are often the result of driver negligence, distractions, or a failure to adhere to the rules of the road. To prevent accidents, it is crucial for drivers to exercise caution, remain attentive, and follow the traffic signs and regulations within parking lots.


What happens when two cars reverse into each other?

When two cars reverse into each other in a parking lot or any other scenario, the situation can be a bit more complicated to determine fault compared to other types of accidents. Here’s what typically happens in such cases:

1. Assessing the Damage: The first step is to assess the extent of the damage to both vehicles. Documenting the damages through photographs and exchanging insurance information is crucial for insurance claims and potential legal proceedings.

2. Gathering Evidence: If there are any witnesses present, it is important to obtain their contact information. Their statements can help provide a clearer picture of the events leading up to the collision. Additionally, surveillance footage from nearby cameras, if available, can be valuable evidence.

3. Insurance Claims: Both drivers should report the accident to their respective insurance companies as soon as possible. Each driver will need to provide their account of the incident and any evidence collected to support their version of events.

4. Insurance Investigation: The insurance companies will conduct their own investigation to determine the liability in the accident. They will consider factors such as the point of impact, the movement of the vehicles, and any other evidence available to them. However, it is important to note that insurance companies may initially assign shared liability or no-fault until a clear determination can be made.

5. Comparative Negligence: In some cases, both drivers may be found partially at fault for the collision. The insurance companies or legal professionals will apply the concept of comparative negligence, where the responsibility for the accident is allocated proportionally between the parties involved based on their respective degree of fault.

6. Legal Proceedings: If the parties involved cannot reach a satisfactory resolution through insurance claims or if there is a dispute regarding fault, legal action may be pursued. In such cases, hiring a car accident attorney who specializes in handling these types of accidents can be beneficial. They can navigate the legal process, gather evidence, and represent the interests of the driver in court if necessary.

Determining fault when two cars reverse into each other requires a thorough examination of the circumstances and evidence. It is crucial to consult with professionals such as insurance adjusters or car accident attorneys who can guide you through the process and help protect your rights and interests.